Seasonal First Impressions is a column where I detail my thoughts, however brief or long, about a currently-airing anime’s first episode or so.
In the grand scheme of all of the anime that have premiered (or have yet to premiere) in the Summer 2026 anime season, my most anticipated show wasn’t the new Kyoto Animation series, ScienceSARU’s take on Ghost in the Shell, the new BanG Dream anime, or anything of the sort. No, I saw that title, and the little bit of atmospheric teasing built up by its first trailer, and—despite knowing nothing at all about the manga it’s based on other than that it’s generally well-liked—knew that it was going to be this. This was my called shot, I’ve been saying for months that this is going to be the premiere of the season; forget whatever hyped-up sequel you have in your mind, the A-O-T-S is I Want To Love You Till Your Dying Day.
Does the actual premiere live up to those predictions? Well, to be perfectly honest, no. Not really. But, I do still think it’s a good premiere. And before I get into why, let’s talk about what this thing actually is first.
Looked at through a certain lens, Dying Day is not terribly different from any of a vast number of ‘magic school’ anime that have existed over the past 15 years. Our protagonist attends an academy that teaches its students how to effectively wield the arcane talents they are born with. The most immediate difference is one of tone; the school of Dying Day is a misty, floodlight gray, and we open in medias res, one of the students having just been killed in a recent “operation.” This school, you see, trains its students not for careers or for their own enrichment, but as soldiers in a war. Young girls and boys learn to conjure magic primarily as a weapon, summoning small, dagger-like wooden wands to do so. The emotional timbre in this opening is more Madoka Magica than Harry Potter, in other words.
Our protagonist is the dead girl’s roommate. In a relatively straightforward move for this show, she’s behind everyone else in her class in terms of talent. Her name is Totsuki Sheena [Takahashi Rie], and she spends most of this episode’s opening minutes wondering why. Why is everyone so blasé about the death of her roommate? Is this how this is all really supposed to be? Flashing back to conversations with that late roommate, Sheena remembers being told she was lucky for being as weak as she was. That her weakness was a privilege that exempted her from thinking about the war. And that night, as she’s continuing to ponder all this, she runs quite unexpectedly into a girl a good bit younger than herself, who is absolutely drenched in blood. Not her own blood, either.
This is Kagari Mimi [Hidaka Rina]. Mimi, who eagerly gobbles up the riceballs that Sheena offers her, is the key to the other half of this show’s tonal space and, I suspect, will be central to whatever it decides to do long-term. (I use that vague phrasing because to be honest, this episode is slow and setup-heavy enough that I don’t really know what that is yet.) Mimi is a few years younger than Sheena and, when she enrolls in Sheena’s class the next day and is announced to be Sheena’s new roommate, the classroom is abuzz with gossip. The other girls (and the boys, too) whisper that Mimi might be that Mimi, a girl who the staff supposedly keep on retainer as some kind of invincible superweapon. In introducing all this, Dying Day does a peculiar little waltz where it tiptoes back into the foggy duskiness of its opening minutes and a goofier sensibility more willing to embrace light novel clichés. In the former camp you have Sheena and Mimi’s wanderings around the school at night, and the funeral for Sheena’s former roommate where Sheena chucks a rabbit into her empty coffin. (The school’s soldiers, we’re told, dissolve instantly upon death. If they were captured, their foes—who we know almost nothing about at this juncture—might “learn things” from their corpses.) In the latter camp, you have everyone’s gleeful fangirling over how cute Mimi is, and one particular detail of the setting; the school’s soldiers (or at least the girls) can kiss each other to use “healing magic.” Essentially, Fate/stay Night‘s “mana transfer” but in slightly less H-game terms. It’s an uneasy dance, but Dying Day largely makes it work.
One of those kisses ends the episode. After witnessing another pair of girls do it, Mimi unexpectedly kisses Sheena when the latter is unable to sleep that night due to stomach problems that, it seems a fair guess, are caused by stress. Sheena narrates that this little problematically age-gapped kiss tastes faintly of soap and, of course, blood…and that’s where the episode ends! Aside from a few minor details (such as a very chummy couple who seem like they’re going to be our main supporting cast) I have really left out very little. It’s a slow, buildup-heavy first episode that is big on atmosphere and raising questions in the mind of its audience. Honestly? Partly because of that uneasy yoyoing between moods, I suspect Dying Day will probably be relegated to cult favorite at best. And even on a technical level it isn’t a perfect premiere. (There are a few obvious visual shortcuts, in particular the use of CGI for some distance models, a general sign of a show that is trying its hardest but isn’t necessarily the most resource-rich production. They’re the only real ding to the otherwise excellent atmosphere.) Still, if you like sapphic overtones so heavy that “overtone” is honestly not the right word anymore and a curious, mysterious atmosphere, I really do think this is worth checking out. Anime of the year? No, not in a year with legitimate masterpieces in this space like Shiboyugi and Kamiina Botan. Of the season? Even then, probably not. But, it is worthwhile in its own right, in a time where everything is rushing to grab your attention as quickly as possible, something taking the slow path shouldn’t be underestimated.
Like what you’re reading? Consider following Magic Planet Anime to get notified when new articles go live. If you’d like to talk to other Magic Planet Anime readers, consider joining my Discord server! Also consider following me on Anilist, BlueSky, or Tumblr and supporting me on Ko-Fi. If you want to read more of my work, consider heading over to the Directory to browse by category.
All views expressed on Magic Planet Anime are solely my own opinions and conclusions and should not be taken to reflect the opinions of any other persons, groups, or organizations. All text is manually typed and edited, and no machine learning or other automatic tools are used in the creation of Magic Planet Anime articles, with the exception of a basic spellchecker. However, some articles may have additional tags placed by WordPress. All text, excepting direct quotations, is owned by Magic Planet Anime. Do not duplicate without permission. All images are owned by their original copyright holders.






































