Seasonal First Impressions is a column where I detail my thoughts, however brief or long, about a currently-airing anime’s first episode or so.
I’ve ended up covering a lot of romcoms in the first impressions column over the years here on Magic Planet Anime. I do not say lightly that this one might be the simplest I’ve ever written about at any length, The Klutzy Class Monitor & The Girl With The Short Skirt is a dead-simple romantic comedy with a zany flair, a retro sensibility, and a knack for comedic timing. The whole premise is in the title: there’s a class monitor at a high school who is kind of a klutz despite his position, there is also a girl at that same high school who wears her skirts short and dyes her hair. They clash in the episode’s opening minutes, a very old-school banter volley where the klutz (Sakuradaimon Togo, played by Enoki Junya) and the girl (Kohinata Poem, Akechi Riko) argue about if her skirt length is actually inappropriate or not. Togo, perhaps not the most feminist young man in Japan, argues that it’s too revealing. Too sexy, even! This promptly gets him punched in the gut.
This kind of yelled insult -> girl punches boy comedy is, by this point in the medium’s history, so ancient that seeing it in something that started airing a mere three days ago (and based on a manga from 2019, when this was already well out of fashion), is novel in of itself. You could pretty easily argue that by parroting the points that he does, Togo is upholding sexist double standards about how women are allowed to dress. He honestly is doing that, and if we were supposed to think Togo was right, as opposed to merely well-intentioned but stupid, I don’t think this show would be very good at all. But what makes the series really tick, assuming this first episode is a good indicator, is its timing and sense of style. The whole pervert slap trope has been largely excised from modern romcoms in place of something more subtle and reflective of how relationships actually work. The visual stylings of the show, so willfully retro that the bright colors and sharp lines are complete with printer dots on the backgrounds, make it clear that this is an intentional pastiche. (Were it not for the presence of smartphones, it’d be easy to assume this was set in the 90s or something.) Togo, who despite being a complete tightwad is also sort of a dumbass who isn’t much for academics, makes an active effort to get to know Poem when they both end up in remedial math lessons. Predictably, she starts falling for him. And again, while there’s obviously an element of turbo-hetero wish fulfillment here, the intentionally stiff and simple emotional beats make for a series that’s….oddly refreshing? Togo and Poem might be polar opposites, but you’d never mistake this show for that one, despite the broadly similar premises and some visual language in common. (Not to mention excellent music.)
If Klutz & Skirt calls back to anything in particular, it feels mostly of a piece with the anime comedies of the mid-2000s. These were usually loosely school life-based, too, but they tended toward the absurd or simply the zany as opposed to harboring any deep storylines or thoughts on life. (They even do that thing I love, once common but now rather rare, where the episode is divided in half by a midcard where a character says the name of the show out loud. A favorite little bauble of mine, I miss it!) A useful synecdoche here is the sheer number of times Poem clobbers Togo—about six, if I counted right in these 20-some minutes alone—that kind of physical abuse just isn’t that common in this genre anymore.
Frankly, if the series has accomplished anything of note here, it’s been making me wonder if I don’t kind of miss this stuff. At the end of the day the subtler emotional currents available to the genre that essentially replaced this one are great, and they’re probably my preference, but there is something to be said for the old-school tsundere category that Poem falls into. This is particularly pronounced when they learn each other’s given names. Poem does not want Togo calling her that, since it’s an embarrassing sparkle name. When he makes a habit of doing so anyway, the predictably percussive occurs. The show just has a nice, snappy rhythm to it, even if it’s working in simple archetypes. The director, Iwanaga Daiji, deserves some real credit here for making the show feel so kinetic.
There’s a solid supporting cast here, too, by the looks of it. We haven’t gotten to know any of them deeply yet, but in the last segment of the episode Akina Motoko [Itou Yuina], one of Poem’s friends, develops a big, pervy crush on a hot health rep after he carries her to the infirmary.
She’s normal.
The other girl in Poem’s clique, Tasaki Rui [Fukuhara Ayaka], we haven’t really learned much about yet, but her very short hair makes her GNC AF. So hey, points.
She also seems to enjoy flustering Poem. Just pointing that out.
I think all I’ve said here will clue you in pretty thoroughly to whether you’d get anything out of Klutz & Skirt. There are different kinds of strong anime seasons, and this one in particular has proven to be the sort that absolutely floods the zone with sheer numbers, there are a lot of things airing right now that are good, a few that are great, and even the stuff that’s less essential is still interesting. It’s said that a rising tide lifts all boats, but I do hope that the slightly more niche stuff like Klutz, fellow oddball romcom Kirio Fan Club (which I’d like to write about at some point, stay tuned?), and so on, don’t get lost in the shuffle. Things like this deserve to find their audience just as much as your Witch Hat Ateliers and Akane-banashis, and I hope they do.
Like what you’re reading? Consider following Magic Planet Anime to get notified when new articles go live. If you’d like to talk to other Magic Planet Anime readers, consider joining my Discord server! Also consider following me on Anilist, BlueSky, or Tumblr and supporting me on Ko-Fi. If you want to read more of my work, consider heading over to the Directory to browse by category.
All views expressed on Magic Planet Anime are solely my own opinions and conclusions and should not be taken to reflect the opinions of any other persons, groups, or organizations. All text is manually typed and edited, and no machine learning or other automatic tools are used in the creation of Magic Planet Anime articles, with the exception of a basic spellchecker. However, some articles may have additional tags placed by WordPress. All text, excepting direct quotations, is owned by Magic Planet Anime. Do not duplicate without permission. All images are owned by their original copyright holders.
The Magic Planet 