Seasonal First Impressions is a column where I detail my thoughts, however brief or long, about a currently-airing anime’s first episode or so.

---

Try to count them and their numbers are endless. Their visages form a parade of baby faces and expressions of bitter smarm; Kazuto “Kirito” Kirigaya, Naofumi Iwatani, Rudeus Greyrat, Takuma “Diablo” Sakamoto. They are ordinary until they aren’t. They are you, dear viewer, and all the strengths and flaws they think you have. They are everyone and no one. For a while, starting up The Executioner and Her Way of Life, it seemed as though we might be able to add a new face to that list.

But looks can be deceiving, and those paying attention will note there is no mention of a “His” anywhere the title. If our little friend there is the main character of some story, it isn’t this one. The show’s opening episode takes just enough time to lead anyone going in blind (like say, yours truly) on that I imagine not everyone will get through it. The ingredients of a deeply generic series are here; That Guy is summoned to another world, ends up in a rough situation, and is pitied and taken care of by an attractive female lead who seems destined to play second-fiddle to him.

But I’m getting ahead of myself. First, a general thought. It is perhaps no surprise that there are few genres of modern anime–few genres of mainstream television period–more maligned than the isekai series. And while any genre so large is bound to produce works that strike outside of the established mold, we have been living in the middle of our own Isekai World for a solid decade now. It’s not just that people are tired of the genre–although that certainly is part of it–it is that they are tired of what the genre represents. The all-shortcuts worldbuilding, the ambient misogyny, the imperialistic undertone of an average Japanese teenager being teleported to an unsullied world only to inevitably dominate it through (depending on the series) some combination of “modern knowledge” and sheer Main Character Status. The problem is far worse the lower the barrier to entry, but plenty of these have seeped into the anime mainstream for years now. Speaking personally, I ignore the vast majority of them unless I’m given good reason to not. Because of that, I’m content to generally not speak on them at all.

But I sort of have to here, because while I myself am pretty down on the genre, I don’t think I hate it nearly as much as whoever wrote Executioner does.

Credit should be given here. Having a bone to pick with something does not mean you understand it, necessarily. But in Executioner‘s opening minutes we get some expository worldbuilding that is displays an intuitive understanding with all the unfortunate implications built into your ISO Standard Isekai Story. The world of the series is frequently visited by “Lost Ones”, people who come from a mysterious otherworld called–you may have heard of it–Japan. Lost Ones are summoned via various means (a scheming king is how our Potato-kun friend ends up here), and inevitably end up bringing knowledge to the world. Our nominal protagonist assumes he can contribute to this tradition, mentioning the wonders of mayonnaise (seriously), to which his tour guide, the aforementioned female co-protagonist Menou (Iori Saeki), replies that it’s “pretty tasty.” Banter of this nature continues; he naturally assumes he will be given free shelter and money since Menou is a priestess (he’s right on the first count, wrong on the second), he idly remarks that another Lost One he saw be summoned “had big boobs”, etc.

^{Can’t you just feel her enthusiasm?}

All the while, Menou patiently explains to him that the world is divided into three classes–Commons (ordinary people), Noblesse (nobles and kings), and Fausts (the clergy, the only one with a slightly odd name) –and it becomes rather difficult for the viewer to not notice that whatever language(s) may have once been spoken in this world, they’ve all been supplanted by Japanese.

So, you have an arrogant asshole of a protagonist who thinks he’s god’s blessing upon this wonderful world despite all evidence to the contrary, and the broad implication that at some point at least some former Lost Ones may have Done An Imperialism with the help of their powers. (Of course they gain magic powers upon being summoned to the new world. This is still an isekai we’re talking about.) But if Executioner stopped there we’d merely be in vaguely ReZero-ish territory. Instead, when Menou helps this guy figure out that his magical power is “Null,” the ability to straight-up erase anything he’d like from existence, she does this.

Again, no “His” in the title.

The lead-on is a touch obvious, maybe. I could tell even from the first few scenes that this wasn’t going to be a straightforward isekai power fantasy, but I was legitimately surprised to see our heroine–our actual protagonist, mind you–straight-up stab someone in the damn head. Really, I shouldn’t have been. It’s right there in the name; she’s an executioner.

If all Executioner had up its sleeve was this single twist, though, I wouldn’t be writing about it at this much length. The fact of the matter is that the series immediately tosses a wrench into its own assumptions as soon as she does the deed. She spares a prayer for him, proving the priestess thing as no ruse, and says that in truth, at least by her own reckoning, he did nothing wrong.

Over the remaining half of the episode, we get a good amount of insight into Menou’s character. She has dreams that imply that she herself might be from another world; a world where she’s an ordinary high school girl and has a best friend who she misses dearly. Her religious devoutness is sincere, and she chastises her clingy lesbian cohort Momo (Hisako Kanemoto) for casual blasphemy. And she has a casual, friendly relationship with one of said religion’s archbishops. (In general, this religion seems awfully Christianity-ish. But whether that’s foreshadowing or just a straight use of a pretty typical fantasy trope is hard to say at this early juncture.) All this works to establish her as someone who grits her teeth and plays this role because she thinks it’s the right thing to do, not necessarily because she finds it pleasant.

In flashback, we learn how she was brought into the fold of “the church”‘s executioners; by being the only survivor of a Lost One accidentally destroying a whole town.

There is some pretty wild imagery in here; the Lost One in question transforming into a huge giant made of white ash after being killed by a different executioner. That’d be the vindictive Flare (Yuuko Kaida), who at the conclusion of the flashback becomes Menou’s mentor.

By now, you get the idea. This is a series that wants to very seriously examine the underlying assumptions of the isekai power fantasy. But the question naturally becomes; once it breaks the genre down, what does it intend to rebuild it into? And in the answer to that question we will find Executioner’s long-term success or failure.

There is always a temptation to refer to things like this as “deconstructions” of the genres they, at least in part, are built to criticize the foundations of. I do not use that word in my writing–not without heavy couching, at the very least–but to me this series does seem to aspire to a certain casual definition of the term. I said before that Executioner feels like it was written by someone who hates isekai, but it’s totally possible that the very opposite is true. Rarely is it easier to see the faults within a genre than when you’re a huge fan of it, and lest we forget, it absolutely is possible to still use this story format for interesting, compelling ends. (Not for nothing was Princess Connect! Re:Dive my favorite anime of last season.)

At the very least, Executioner seems allergic to easy outs. In addition to our protagonist’s own judgment of her morality, the task she’s sent upon at episode’s end involves seeking out another Lost One, who seems suspiciously evocative of the girl from her dreams. (And who herself dreamed of the other world before arriving there.) The question then becomes, obviously, how hardline she’s willing to be, and what Executioner can do with whatever the result is. The episode ends on this cold confrontation, questions hanging in the air with answers far off and out of sight.

Personally, I’m absolutely fascinated by this series. (Its devastatingly kickass OP helps, too.) But I will admit that I’m something of a genre outsider. So for any true isekai fans who happen to read this, I’d be interested to see what such might think of it.

As for everyone else? It’s been a strong season already, but there’s something special about this one, I can feel it.

The Takeaway: Unless you’re simply averse to the very premise, I’d give Executioner at least a few episodes. For some of you, the mere fact of seeing Cute Anime Girls go all stone-cold killer might be enough of a draw. And hey, if that’s so, no judgment from me.

---

Like what you’re reading? Consider following Magic Planet Anime to get notified when new articles go live. If you’d like to talk to other Magic Planet Anime readers, consider joining my Discord server! Also consider following me on Twitter and supporting me on Ko-Fi or Patreon. If you want to read more of my work, consider heading over to the Directory to browse by category.

All views expressed on Magic Planet Anime are solely my own opinions and conclusions and should not be taken to reflect the opinions of any other persons, groups, or organizations. All text, excepting direct quotations, is owned by Magic Planet Anime. Do not duplicate without permission. All images are owned by their original copyright holders.